Sunday, May 26, 2013

Notes from a Climate Scientist: Bark up THIS Tree!


I spent the first half of this week at The Yellowstone Business Partnership's 10th anniversary conference, with the magnificent backdrop of the Tetons, looking back at our past 10 years of challenges and accomplishments, and planning ahead for our next 10.  Perhaps my favorite session, after the inspiring allegory by author Gary Ferguson about Nature as the Great Equalizer (the sow griz with cubs doesn't care who has the most money, or the bluest blood.  She'll deliver her butt kicking to whoever is the biggest threat!), was Dr. Steve Running's report on the latest climate science.  Dr. Running won the Nobel Peace Prize in 2007 for his work with Al Gore and the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change.  Our executive director had asked him to give "an inspiring climate talk"...to which he replied: "...?..."

Carbon dioxide has risen by 36% since accurate measurements began in 1958.  Just two weeks ago, a milestone (and not in a good way): Earth's CO2 level passes 400 parts per million, "for the first time in 55 years of measurement, and probably more than 3 million years of Earth history." Major bummer.

Dr. Running outlined the global implications, as well as those that hit closer to home.  He really hit home with this graph and this sobering statement: "Until we shut down coal power, NOTHING else we do will matter."


It doesn't take a rocket scientist to realize from this graph that coal accounts for 43% of global emissions in 2011.  Living in Montana, coal is a hot button issue.  We have coal aplenty, so much coal that our ex-Governor is the biggest proponent of the benefits of "clean coal"; Dr. Running says the industry is talking about it but they aren't doing it, there is no technological basis for even testing the idea of "cleaner coal".  Here are just a few of the current controversies or "campaigns" surrounding coal in my beautiful home state:
  • In Montana, Ranchers Line Up Against Coal: A ranching family that has been on their land for the past 125 years, now at risk of losing the viability of their 31,000 acres because of groundwater and aquifer contamination and the proposed Tongue River Railroad cutting through 9 miles of their ranch
  • Count on Coal Montana: "All Montanans benefit from affordable electricity, job creation and state tax revenue when Montana produces and sells its abundant coal resources. These benefits are threatened by environmental activists who seek to end or minimize coal production in Montana, drive up our electricity rates and prevent Montanans from taking advantage of our most abundant natural and economic resource."
  • Port Cities Protest: The Leadership Alliance Against Coal, the coalition formed by the Seattle mayor and other city and tribal leaders concerned about the impacts that increased coal train traffic through Washington state will have on traffic, public health and the environment

The Union of Concerned Scientists released a 2012 report titled "Ripe for Retirement: The Case for Closing America's Costliest Coal Plants", which makes the case for great opportunity to accelerate the transition to a clean energy economy.  The report reveals that more than 3/4 of America's coal-fired power plants have outlived their 30-year lifespan, with 17 being older than 50 years.  They are inefficient, and cannot meet emissions standards.  "They lack essential modern pollution controls, so they damage public health. The sulfur they emit causes acid rain. The mercury they release poisons waterways and fish and causes neurological damage in children (EPA 2012). The soot they emit creates smog that causes lung disease, premature death, and triggers asthma attacks (EPA 2010a; NRC 2010). Burning coal demands billions of gallons of cooling water from vulnerable rivers and lakes, and leaves behind vast quantities of toxic ash residuals, while coal mining causes extensive and lasting damage both to human health and the natural environment (Gentner 2010; NRC 2010)."  The US is slowing down coal fired power plants, because the old plants can’t meet mercury emisisons standards and aren’t grandfathered in any more.  So the new strategy is to ship it to China.  Why not?  Outta sight, outta mind, right?  

This photo is taken in Missoula, MT, my hometown.  The parking lot on the right is the nursing home where my mom works.  The train cars in the background are transporting Montana coal west to Seattle and then on to China.  She spends the majority of her time, right here with these osprey, breathing in this coal dust and oblivious to the dangers rumbling by on the tracks.  Is she getting mercury poisoning, from walking to her car every day and working for 12 hours in a building with air circulated from outside?  Outta sight, outta mind?  Not so much.


So this scares me, and pisses me off.  Why is this so hard for us to understand?

Monday, May 20, 2013

The question is....

In my last blog post, I delved into the "science" of climate change denial.  

Here are some resources you can use in your conversations with climate deniers; not to debate climate change (there is no debate, only a wildly successful misinformation campaign), but to understand deniers most commonly used arguments and be able to articulately respond.  99 one-liners to rebut climate denier arguments--with links to the full climate science.  For example,

And perhaps my favorite, here is a kick ass infographic to assist you further:


97% of climate scientists agree: global warming is happening and we are the cause. 


The question is, what are we going to do about it? 


Sunday, May 12, 2013

Unicorns Exist! The Science of Climate Change Denial


For the past 2½ terms in team climate, and prior to that in my professional world, I’ve wondered with mild curiosity and increasing frustration how we are still “debating” climate change.  No longer are we calling it global warming (“we had the coldest winter in ages!” is a common rebuttal; global weirding seems a more appropriate term), but semantics aside, there is still an outspoken faction of the American people who don’t believe this is a problem. 

How does this happen?  Why are so many seemingly intelligent, educated people so vehemently denying that a) climate change is happening (or even that the greenhouse effect does in fact exist); or b) that it’s human-caused?  For perspective, I’ve started reading climate denier sites and articles, and especially the comments, to better understand this strong conviction of my fellow Americans. 

Some of the more entertaining comments I’ve come across:
  • Climate change believers are “political radicals who want to destroy western civilization so that they can bring to fruition their dream of a great socialist utopia. It has nothing to do with science.”
  • “GHGs don’t cause warming any more than insulating my house causes it to heat up.”
  • “Applying scientific argument to political BS is like expecting math rules to apply in English class. The name of the joint is your tipoff: InterGOVERNMENTAL Panel on Climate Change.”
  •  “For the rest of us the “globalony” issue is just a global IQ test. If you believe mankind can affect the global climate either way, you fail the test. And really, there is no need to get into the weeds on this issue. If you believe man can affect the global climate, you are an easily fooled imbecile.”  

There seem to be constant media battles on climate change.  An article last month on Fox News takes a 10 year leveling temperature reading to “disprove” the data from the past several hundred thousand years: “Climate change skeptics seize on reports showing temperatures leveling”.  "The idea that CO2 is the tail that wags the dog is no longer scientifically tenable," said Marc Morano of ClimateDepot.com, a website devoted to countering the prevailing acceptance of man-made global warming.  "In the peer-reviewed literature we're finding hundreds of factors influence global temperature, everything from ocean cycles to the tilt of the earth's axis to water vapor, methane, cloud feedback, volcanic dust, all of these factors are coming together. They're now realizing it wasn't the simple story we've been told of your SUV is creating a dangerously warm planet." 

There is still vast confusion among the general public, many of whom believe that scientists are not in agreement about human-caused global warming.  James Lawrence Powell, Executive Director of the National Physical Science Consortium, who holds a PhD in Geochemistry from MIT and doctor of Science degrees from Oberlin and Berea Colleges, conducted a study to settle this question of whether scientists are in agreement about anthropogenic climate change.

Of the 13,950 peer reviewed climate articles from 1991-2012, 24 “reject” human-caused global warming (see this great pie chart detailing “Why Climate Change Deniers have no scientific credibility).  Stated another way, of 33,700 authors of peer reviewed climate change papers, only 34 reject that it’s caused by humans.  And from an earlier study (Oreskes, Science 2005) cited by Powell (and introduced to me by our lead instructor for the UnCommon Sense Business Response to Climate Change module):

Someone who doesn’t understand science will never understand the importance of science.  But someone who is constantly bombarded by misinformation and by the media will have a hell of a time discerning what is true and what is hogwash.  I work in this field and still get overwhelmed by all the information and data.  I can only imagine how difficult it is for the average person to obtain accurate, simple to understand information to be able to form an educated opinion or have an understanding of the issue. 

I just started reading “Merchants of Doubt: How a Handful of Scientists Obscured the Truth on Issues from Tobacco Smoke to Global Warming”.  It turns out that there is a war being waged against the scientists who are providing evidence of human-caused climate change.  The Guardian reported in 2007 that scientists and economists were being offered $10K to “undermine a major climate change report” from the IPCC; an Exxon Mobil/Koch/American Petroleum Institute funded scientist is writing papers to flat out dismiss climate change.  Conservative Think Tanks are rolling out studies and providing highly paid lobbyists to cast doubt on the “science of climate change”.  Not only the same tactics that were used in trying to convince the American public that smoking wasn’t bad for us, but the same lobbyists, the very same people. 

It hurts my head to read much of this, where it feels more like smoke and mirrors diversion tactics than an actual rebuttal to scientific findings.  One could easily get lost in the weeds and never find their way out (though if you’re interested, this library is a good place to start looking for climate denier links and references).

There is a faint glimmer of light with our sitting President, however.  Our EcoSecurities case cited that the leading candidates for the 2008 Presidential election all had endorsed binding emissions reduction targets and a domestic carbon market.  Upon reading this, I groaned, knowing how far those endorsements had gotten us in reality.  Imagine my surprise when on April 25th, President Obama tweeted to encourage the American people to urge Congress to stop ignoring climate science:


They circulated a petition to call out Climate Deniers in Congress.   And I got this email in my inbox, inviting me to sign the petition and hold climate deniers accountable.  The subject line: Unicorns Exist**.  And the icing on the cake: “The sticky thing about the truth is that it’s the truth whether Congress likes it or not.”



Now, I’m game for anything using Unicorns in an argument.  But the Organizing for Action campaign is getting flack for stretching the truth a bit on this effort.  In a video accompanying this media blitz, OfA claims that 240 House members voted that climate change was a “hoax”.  The video is quite entertaining and more than a little scary, given the perspectives within. 

A recent Washington Post (and others) article states that the campaign “misleadingly cites a vote” on a climate change bill.  “We’ve written before about the growing consensus among climate researchers that climate change is the result of human activity; there’s little debate about that among scientists, though surveys show increasing skepticism among the American public. But we were intrigued by the video’s claim that 240 House lawmakers had declared climate change to be a ‘hoax.’”

The 240 House members apparently voted against an amendment to a proposed bill on taking regulatory power for carbon emissions away from the EPA and giving it to Congress.  That amendment said: "Congress accepts the scientific findings of the Environmental Protection Agency that climate changes is occurring, is caused largely by human activities, and poses significant risks for public health and welfare."  Sheesh.  Might as well be voting that climate change is a hoax. 

As long as we keep going round and round on semantics, we will remain in a life-threatening stale mate until this great Earth gets tired of our shenanigans and neatly stamps out our species.  Just this morning I got an email from 350.org with the news that on May 9th, the carbon counter on Mauna Loa observatory recorded a daily average of above 400 parts per million.  Which, according to a lot of people, is bad.  Really bad.  What the (bleep) will it take, people?!?

Sunday, February 24, 2013

Help me, President Obama...


It’s been an interesting two weeks.  I’ve had quite a few moments of sheer dumbfoundedness, many relating to topics that inform my research for and work on Team Climate. 

In a testimony for a bill to expand net metering (Senate bill 247) at the Montana legislature, Northwestern Energy made clear that they are not fans of net metering.  In fact, it seems that NWE believes that net metering is a “subsidy for the upper middle class and the wealthy of society, paid for by other ratepayers.”  The NWE spokesperson called it a “nuisance” and an “experiment in social engineering”.  As Montana’s largest electric utility,

That’s not the only “…what the…?” instance I came across this week.  Again from my home state (I’m so proud…), House Bill Number 549: “…global warming is beneficial to the welfare and business climate of Montana.”  That’s on par with North Carolina legislating against sea level rise.  As if we can pass a law to turn facts into opinion.  I particularly enjoyed the tongue-in-cheek with both of these articles—they are worth the read.  “Cigarettes killing too many people? Write a law saying they don't! Think gravity is an unnecessary burden on our airline industry? Let's vote it away! Evolution doesn't fit your religious beliefs? Outlaw it!”

A recent Environmental Leader article outlines the bottom line costs of countless delays or roadblocks for renewable energy projects in “The Real Cost of NIMBYism”.  The author cites a statistic from an initiative called Project No Project (conspicuously an initiative of the US Chamber of Commerce—will have to look deeper into that), which “assesses the broad range of energy projects that are being stalled, stopped, or outright killed nationwide due to “Not In My Back Yard” (NIMBY) activism, a broken permitting process and a system that allows limitless challenges by opponents of development”: Project No Project estimates that in the short term the 351 projects analyzed could produce $1.1 trillion for the economy and create 1.9 million jobs a year. Also once these projects are created and established, they are estimated to produce $145 billion and create 791,000 jobs.  That’s a lot of money.  And a lot of jobs. 

All seriousness aside (or all jokes?  It’s hard to tell these days with such radical topics), I did come across a few exciting initiatives that I hope will gain traction.  The first article that gives me hope is a new partnership between Honda/Acura and Solar City, where Honda/Acura customers can purchase a solar system at little or no upfront cost in exchange for a long-term contract in which the customer pays a fixed fee for the electricity generated, set at less than the customer would pay for power from the local utility.  Honda will provide $65M in financing for installation of new systems.  The customer gets cheaper power and doesn’t have to front the money—what’s not to like? 

The second one caught me by the title alone: “Won’t you be my solar-power-buying neighbor?”.  It questions why Germany, which has 15% less annual sun than Puget Sound, is kicking our ass in the solar arena.  They have great incentives, and solar is accessible to everyone—it has become the norm.  Solarize Washington is following Germany’s lead and piloting an effort to build critical mass to make solar more accessible in the PNW.  The project has incentives aplenty: 30% federal tax credit; state sales tax exemption if a solar system is purchased by June 30th; annual production incentive capped at five thousand a year through June 2020; and fifteen cents per kilowatt hour for solar systems made out of state and fifty-four cents per kilowatt hour for those made in-state.

Another reason the solar in Germany is so successful is that it is also primarily distributed, community owned power, not corporation or utility owned; individuals or communities own 51% of solar in Germany, and over 100 rural communities are now powered by 100% renewable energy.  It’s a David and Goliath story, where Germany is David and the U.S. is Goliath: “The US is slowly switching to renewables, but it is nearly completely shutting out the little guy, with only two percent of installed wind power capacity not owned by giant corporations. And when it comes to solar in the US, almost everything is utility-scale plants. The changes in Germany are driven by the little guy, whereas the renewable industry in the US is controlled by some of the world’s biggest multinational companies.”

I don’t know about you, but I’ve been to Germany.  It’s gray.  And rainy.  If solar can triumph there, then why can’t we make it work here?  The little guys and gals in this country need to band together and drive the change that we need. 

Perhaps the most uplifting read was from OnEarth on President Obama’s message to Congress: “If Congress won’t act soon to protect future generations, I will. I will direct my Cabinet to come up with executive actions we can take, now and in the future, to reduce pollution, prepare our communities for the consequences of climate change, and speed the transition to more sustainable sources of energy.”  The article outlines the various options for action either with Congress on board, or actions he can take that don’t need congressional approval.  Let’s hope that Obama’s David can triumph over the congressional Goliath.  Help me, President Obama.  You’re my only hope.  


Sunday, February 10, 2013

The World's a Mess but I'm Busy.


Here among team climate, there is a long-standing shared priority/joke/frustration: how do we get people to connect their short-term actions with long-term ramifications?  Why is this such a hard thing to understand?  Is it denial? Do people genuinely believe that there is no cause for alarm?  Is it belief overshadowed by the feeling of insignificance, being overwhelmed by the immensity of climate change and feeling that nothing we do will make a difference?  Is it because people feel there are other, more pressing issues to address first?  Is it that we just don’t give a sh*t?



The throwaway society depicted by Life Magazine in 1955 heralded single use products and the “liberation of the American housewife”.   This only fueled the fire of consumerism, and propelled us down a path of resource depletion and a sense of entitlement for whatever the Earth may provide.

It seems that lately concern for environmental issues has been on the decline.  A recent GreenBiz article explains why we’re tuned out to environmental crises.   GlobeScan’s environmental polling points to the severe economic strife over the past several years: “The full ramifications of the banking collapses, ensuing government bailouts and cripplingly high levels of public indebtedness that have resulted have only slowly become apparent. And bluntly, for many citizens, these appear to pose a much clearer and more present threat to their well-being than environmental jeopardy, which for most people remains hidden from view.”  Barely half of those polled considered climate change a “very serious problem”.   The article also highlights the challenges with misinformation and contradictions: the oil shortage coinciding with the shale boom, species loss being widely exaggerated, and faulty figures on glacier melt in the Himalayas issued by the IPCC, which is supposed to be the expert on such things. 



In another article exploring denial as a barrier to sustainable change, the author talks about meeting with chief executives in the U.K. to discuss sustainability.  From one executive he got this reaction: “…in the current difficult economic climate we are unable to talk about sustainability issues in the public domain because shareholders would view it as us taking our eye off the ball of short term profits growth.”  Yikes. 

He concludes with a bit of positivity, looking at an inter-disciplinary approach to the problem, including neuroscience, positive psychology and Buddhism.  His interview with Thich Nhat Hanh revealed some harsh reality coupled with optimism:  "When they see the truth it is too late to act ... but they don't want to wake up because it may make them suffer; they cannot confront the truth. It is not that they don't know what is going to happen. They just don't want to think about it.  They want to get busy in order to forget. We should not talk in terms of what they should do, what they should not do, for the sake of the future. We should talk to them in such a way that touches their hearts, which helps them to engage on the path that will bring them true happiness, the path of love and understanding, the courage to let go. When they have tasted a little bit of peace and love, they may wake up."

Then there are the challenges of false optimism and the psychology of climate change denial.  We must understand why it’s important to not gloss over the issues, and enable people to sit with the difficult reality of a changing world.  True, Pacific Islands that will be underwater in a decade are distant and abstract to most of us; does this change when we start to see the effects of climate change in our own back yard?  One would think so; alas, this isn’t always the case.  Nic Marks, creator of the Happy Planet Index, helps outline the issues: "What we now see is climate change skepticism increasing as the science base increases, so what's happening is people are mentally fleeing the problem because they're frightened. It's too difficult; it's too big to deal with, so they'd rather believe it doesn't exist and that scientists have got it wrong.”

So where do we go from here?  Do we paint a rosy picture, to give people hope for the future and the feeling that “every CFL counts”?  Do we continue with doom and gloom?  Or do we just stick our head in the sand, and ignore the oncoming freight train?  I’m hoping we can get our collective sh*t together and quit being so apathetic.


Sunday, February 3, 2013

I can see clearly now, the rain is gone...




Climate Change is such a big, overwhelming, seemingly unfixable problem at times.  So in light of optimism, I’m shifting it up a bit this week to talk about some of the amazing and innovative new technologies being explored.  There are too many to include in one post, so perhaps I’ll revisit this topic when I start to get depressed and need some inspiration instead (like when I read about energy innovations from the MIT Technology Review and the headline states: “Notable advances in renewable energy pale compared to the impact of shale gas.”  Sigh.   

How about solar paint that can be painted onto any surface?  Wind turbines that are based on the shape of whale and dolphin flippers, capitalizing on the vortices formed in their wakes?



Hairy solar panels inspired by moth’s eyes, creating a design to mimic their anti-reflectivity, or butterfly wings and their honeycomb structures that increase the efficiency of light harvesting?  



Or what about an underwater turbine that can generate energy from the tidal currents or ocean waves? 


Biofuels from algae, that can grow anywhere, multiply quickly and produce 15 times more oil per acre than other biofuel fodder such as corn or switch grass? 

NASA is developing a plane wing that could cut fuel consumption in half compared to traditional aircraft.  This would have an extraordinary impact on emissions, given the global society we have created. 

One that is certainly intriguing is Cool Planet Biofuels, an up and coming startup funded by Google, BP, General Electric, and ConocoPhillips, among others.  Cool Planet’s founder, Mike Cheiky, claims his biotechnology can create limitless, inexpensive gasoline with negative emissions, while creating arable land at the same time.  The process, being tested at a small scale, takes biomass, turns it into gasoline, then uses plant photosynthesis to remove CO2 from the atmosphere.
“Our proprietary biomass fractionator technology extracts useful hydrocarbons from biomass leaving behind the excess carbon as a high purity solid. The process generates activated carbon with a very high surface area which will allow it to be used as a soil enhancer creating soil similar to "terra preta." By burying this carbon in an appropriate manner, we can greatly enhance soil fertility while sequestering carbon for hundreds of years. In contrast, normal plant decomposition occurs in just a few years, releasing the plant's carbon as CO2 and even more harmful methane gas. Our process yields about the same amount of carbon as gasoline so, if we sequester this carbon as a soil enhancer, or simply bury it as coal, the associated fuel has a full Carbon Negative Rating.”
Is this too good to be true?  Only time will tell.  At least they have some big money behind them to give it a legitimate try.

Solar Roadways is a company I’m pulling for; if their technology catches on it will kill two birds with one stone, and revolutionize our relationship with both transportation (a huge contributor to global warming) and energy consumption.  The concept is simple—replace asphalt and concrete surfaces with solar panels that can be driven on.  It has evolved to include LED lights to make up the “painted” lines, and a heating element to prevent snow and ice from accumulating on the roadway.  They are currently building a prototype parking lot.  I am particularly fond of this one since they live in Sandpoint Idaho, my neighbors to the northwest, and are just regular (albeit super smart) people whose idea has the potential to change the world.